PsychologyOrbit
Sign in Join

#4 · week of

Ethics dilemma of the week

A realistic case with no easy answer. Verified professionals vote with a short reason; voting closes at the end of .

What is the ethics dilemma of the week?

Each week PsychologyOrbit posts one fictional but realistic ethics case from therapy, research, supervision, assessment or work psychology. Members with a verified professional badge choose a course of action and give a short reason; everyone can read the results once the week ends.

Cases are fictional. Code sections are cited by number; read the codes themselves on their official pages.

Fictional case Work & organisational · Bengaluru, India

The confidential 360 and the promotion list

Priya Raman, an organisational psychologist, is running a 360-degree feedback programme for forty middle managers at a mid-sized software firm. Before the survey opened, she and the head of HR told every participant in writing that the results were for personal development only, that individual reports would go to them and their coach, and that management would see only group summaries. Response rates were high and comments were candid. Now the managing director, Mr Vikram Shetty, who signs the consultancy's invoices, asks Priya to send him the individual reports for six managers being considered for promotion. He says the company paid for the data, that he needs the best information to make fair decisions, and that he will keep the reports private. The contract does not say who owns the reports.

What should Priya do?

  1. A Decline to share individual reports and remind him in writing of what participants were promised.
  2. B Offer a separate, properly consented assessment designed for the promotion decision.
  3. C Ask the six managers whether they are willing to share their own reports, making clear that refusing has no consequence.
  4. D Send the reports, because the client paid for the work and the contract is silent on ownership.
Voting is for verified professionals Sign in to vote if you hold a verified licence, professional or researcher badge. Everyone can read the results when the week ends.

This case is fictional, written for discussion. Any resemblance to real people is unintended.

When can I see the results?

Results, colleagues' reasons and the reviewer note appear once you vote, and for everyone after Sunday 22 November, when the week ends.