PsychologyOrbit
Sign in Join

#1 · week of

Ethics dilemma #1: The head teacher on the waiting list

A past case, with how professionals voted and a reviewer note. This week's dilemma.

Fictional case Therapy · Abbottabad, Pakistan

The case

Dr Sana Qureshi is the only clinical psychologist in a small hill town. Her ten-year-old daughter attends a private school of about three hundred pupils. The head teacher, Mr Farhan Abbasi, phones her clinic and asks for an appointment. He says he has been sleeping badly since his wife died last year and that his family doctor suggested therapy. The nearest other psychologist is a three-hour drive away, and online sessions with someone in a city would cost more than he can afford. Dr Sana sees Mr Abbasi at parent meetings several times a year, and next spring he will chair the panel that decides scholarships, for which her daughter has applied. He tells her he trusts her precisely because she knows the community. Her receptionist has already pencilled him in for Thursday.

What should Dr Sana do?

  1. A Take him on, discussing the dual role openly, agreeing boundaries in writing and arranging peer consultation throughout.
  2. B Take him on only after he agrees to step back from the scholarship panel this year.
  3. C Decline and refer him to an online psychologist, helping him look for a lower-cost or sliding-scale option.
  4. D Offer an assessment and a few sessions while actively helping him find a longer-term alternative.

This case is fictional, written for discussion. Any resemblance to real people is unintended.

How did professionals vote?

No votes were cast.

What should be weighed?

Multiple relationships are not banned outright; the question is whether this one risks impairing her objectivity or exploiting him, and whether refusing would leave him with no care at all. In rural settings overlapping roles are often unavoidable, and many ethicists accept them when the psychologist names the overlap, sets clear limits and consults. The scholarship decision adds a conflict of interest that runs in both directions: he may feel under pressure, or others may suspect favour. Reasonable professionals differ on whether managing it is enough or whether referral is safer. Whatever she chooses, recording her reasoning, getting informed consent about the limits of the arrangement, and reviewing it if the overlap grows are widely agreed steps. Her own regulator's guidance on dual relationships applies.

Relevant code sections

Reviewer note written by PsychologyOrbit with AI assistance to support discussion; it has not yet been reviewed by a named psychologist. It is not legal or regulatory advice: your own code, regulator and local law decide. Sections are cited by number; read the codes on their official pages.