PsychologyOrbit
Sign in Join

#2 · week of

Ethics dilemma #2: "I could hurt her for this"

A past case, with how professionals voted and a reviewer note. This week's dilemma.

Fictional case Therapy · Leeds, UK

The case

Daniel, 34, has been seeing counselling psychologist Dr Helen Okafor for six weeks about anger and low mood after a difficult separation. Today he arrives agitated: his former partner has applied to limit his contact with their son. Halfway through the session he says, 'Honestly, I could hurt her for this.' When Dr Okafor asks what he means, he laughs it off, says he would never do anything, and changes the subject. He has no history of violence that she knows of, no access to weapons that he has mentioned, and he describes no plan. At intake he signed a consent form explaining that confidentiality may be broken if someone is at serious risk. He has worked hard in therapy and told her last week that she is the first person he has been honest with. The session ends in ten minutes, and he is clearly embarrassed about what he said.

What should Dr Okafor do?

  1. A Use the remaining time to explore the statement with a structured risk assessment, then decide and record what follows.
  2. B Treat it as venting, note it in the record, and revisit it at the next session.
  3. C Tell Daniel she must now inform the police or his former partner, because any stated threat has to be reported.
  4. D Ask him to stay a little longer or return tomorrow, and consult a senior colleague today before deciding.

This case is fictional, written for discussion. Any resemblance to real people is unintended.

How did professionals vote?

No votes were cast.

What should be weighed?

The tension is between confidentiality and the duty to manage risk to an identifiable person. The UK has no single statutory duty-to-warn rule of the kind some US states have; disclosure without consent is generally justified only where the risk of serious harm is real and the disclosure is proportionate. A remark made in anger and quickly retracted is common in therapy and is not by itself evidence of intent, but it should not simply be ignored. Most practitioners would explore it now, building on the consent conversation already held, and consult. Reasonable people differ on how much weight one statement deserves. A clear record of what was said, what was asked, what was decided and why matters either way. Employer policy and the HCPC standards on confidentiality and risk apply.

Relevant code sections

Reviewer note written by PsychologyOrbit with AI assistance to support discussion; it has not yet been reviewed by a named psychologist. It is not legal or regulatory advice: your own code, regulator and local law decide. Sections are cited by number; read the codes on their official pages.