PsychologyOrbit
Sign in Join

#3 · week of

Ethics dilemma #3: A message nobody can answer

A past case, with how professionals voted and a reviewer note. This week's dilemma.

This case involves suicide or self-harm If you or someone you know is at risk right now, contact your local emergency number or a crisis line. Crisis lines by country.

Fictional case Research · Dhaka, Bangladesh

The case

Dr Nusrat Jahan runs an anonymous online survey on wellbeing among university students in Bangladesh. To protect privacy, and because the ethics committee approved it that way, the survey collects no names, email addresses or IP addresses. The information sheet lists a national helpline and the university counselling centre. Reviewing the free-text answers two weeks after launch, her research assistant finds one entry, submitted four days earlier, in which a participant writes that they have been planning to end their life after their exams and that nobody would miss them. There is no way to identify the person. The survey is still open and will run for another month, with several hundred more students expected to take part. The research assistant is shaken and asks whether they have done something wrong and what they should do now.

What should Dr Nusrat do?

  1. A Report the entry to the ethics committee, review how the survey handles distress, and support the shaken assistant.
  2. B Add a visible support message and helpline details to the end page and to every question that touches on mood.
  3. C Change the survey to collect optional contact details so that future participants at risk could be reached.
  4. D Pause the survey until the committee has reviewed the safeguarding plan with the team.

This case is fictional, written for discussion. Any resemblance to real people is unintended.

How did professionals vote?

No votes were cast.

What should be weighed?

Nobody can be reached here, which is painful, but it follows from a design the committee approved to protect participants. The questions now are what can still be done and what should change. Most would agree the committee should hear about it promptly and that the team, including the assistant, needs support. Reasonable researchers differ on adding optional contact details: it may let help reach someone, but it weakens the anonymity that made honest answers possible and creates a duty to read responses quickly and act on them. Showing support resources at the point where distress is likely, not only on the information sheet, is a common improvement. Whether to pause depends on how fast changes can be made. Local law and the committee's rules decide what is required.

Relevant code sections

Reviewer note written by PsychologyOrbit with AI assistance to support discussion; it has not yet been reviewed by a named psychologist. It is not legal or regulatory advice: your own code, regulator and local law decide. Sections are cited by number; read the codes on their official pages.