The study
Fourteen GP practices around Manchester screened 2,300 adult patients with the GAD-7 anxiety questionnaire during routine appointments. The 180 patients with the highest scores, all 15 or above, were posted a self-help leaflet on managing worry and invited to complete the GAD-7 again six weeks later. Of these, 171 returned it. Their average score fell from 17.2 at screening to 11.9 at follow-up, and a paired t-test showed the change was significant (p < .001). The project team reported that the leaflet cut anxiety by almost a third and recommended that practices across the region post it to every patient who screens high.
What is the flaw in this study?
- A Ceiling effect
- B Survivorship bias
- C Regression to the mean The flaw
- D Multiple comparisons without correction
The concept: Regression to the mean after extreme scores
This study is fictional, written for practice. No real study, institution or researcher is described.