The study
A psychology lab in Cardiff tested whether background noise harms sustained attention. Forty-eight students each completed the same 20-minute computer task, pressing a key whenever a rare target appeared, under two conditions. Everyone did the task first while calm instrumental music played, then immediately afterwards a second time while recorded open-plan office noise played. Errors rose from an average of 12 in the music condition to 19 in the noise condition, a significant increase on a paired t-test. The authors conclude that office noise damages attention and recommend that employers create quiet zones for focused work.
What is the flaw in this study?
- A Survivorship bias
- B Base-rate neglect
- C Order effects (no counterbalancing) The flaw
- D Restriction of range
The concept: Counterbalancing in repeated-measures designs
This study is fictional, written for practice. No real study, institution or researcher is described.