The study
A health ministry review in Bangladesh compared two district clinics that each treated 1,000 adults for depression in a year. At Clinic A, 600 patients (60%) recovered; at Clinic B, 700 (70%). The appendix gives more detail. Clinic A, which takes referrals from across the division, saw 700 severe cases and 300 mild ones; Clinic B saw 200 severe and 800 mild. Among severe cases, 50% recovered at A and 40% at B. Among mild cases, 83% recovered at A and 78% at B. The ministry ranked Clinic B the better clinic and plans to train Clinic A's staff in Clinic B's methods.
What is the flaw in this study?
- A Ceiling effect
- B Simpson's paradox The flaw
- C Demand characteristics
- D Order effects
The concept: Aggregated data can reverse a trend
This study is fictional, written for practice. No real study, institution or researcher is described.